Sometimes, a shirt is not just a shirt

In July 1969, I watched, with my family, as the Eagle lunar module touched down on the moon and Neil Armstrong took humanity’s first steps out there. I remember some of the details of that day with great clarity, others not so well. A couple of things that must have been true on that day were: my dad came home from work and hung out on the couch while my mom made dinner; and the childhood dream of “being an astronaut” may have been considered possible for me, but not for my sisters.

Today, in 2014, I watched, alone in my office, as the Philae lander disconnected from the Rosetta spacecraft and touched down on a comet 500,000,000 km away from here. In some ways we’ve made great progress in those 45 years; in some ways we haven’t.

I want to talk about “the shirt”. But first, a preamble . . .

A ridiculous paper was published a few weeks ago that claimed that we’ve pretty much solved the sexism problem in academia.  The paper was followed up by an Op-Ed piece in the New York Times that made the same argument even more clearly. Well, no. No, we haven’t. Rebuttals and takedowns of all the faulty assumptions, interpretations and conclusions in that paper were swift, and many, and loud (two great examples by Emily Willingham and Jonathan Eisen are here) as they should have been. Science does have a sexism problem, and that problem is manifested in many ways, both subtle and overt. We see ample evidence of it on social media, in the literature, in line-ups of invited speakers at symposia and panels, or in any random subset of tweets from people like Richard Dawkins. I won’t bother linking up to any of the many examples here, you just need to spend any amount of time interacting with scientists on Twitter to see how widespread the problem is.

Now back to the comet . . .

In the internet age, big exciting events get lots of media coverage, and that coverage is immediate and wide-ranging. So the people at the control centre for the European Space Agency kind of had to know there’d be some TV coverage of the comet landing today, and the key players in the mission could have probably assumed they’d be interviewed. But despite all that, for some unknown reason, project scientist Matt Taylor decided to wear this shirt to work today:

The Shirt; The Shirt

The Shirt; The Shirt

Now, ok, I understand that many of us become scientists because we’re unconventional, because we’re individuals, because we’re quirky. Sure, some of us dress funny. I know lots of scientists, great scientists, who are pretty fond of Hawaiian shirts. But, really, seriously, did it not occur to Matt Taylor for maybe just a nanosecond, that appearing on camera, as a scientist, at a defining moment in the history of space exploration, in a shirt festooned with sprawling half-naked women (and a couple o’ guns) might, I dunno, send the wrong goddamn message?!?!

Here’s the thing. I’m a 50-something, white, male scientist. This means that, in the traditional structure of science and academia, I’ve had it pretty easy. Harder than some, but easier than most. But I have to say, from my position as a 50-something, white, male scientist, that it’s about time science had a lot more people who do not look like me. We need diversity, and we need it badly. We need to make science and research and academia a fair and welcoming place for people who are not white, straight, males. I’m not entirely sure how we’re going to get there. But there are two things I do know for certain:

1. We are only going to get there if senior, white dudes like me either step up and say “yes, let’s change things” and then work to make that change happen, or just shut up and get out of the way.

2. We are not going to get there if some of our visible scientists use their brief moments in the spotlight to convey a message (unintentional or not!) that females are better suited to being decorations than to being colleagues.

Science took a huge step forward today, and, thanks to one dumb fashion choice, one step back.




About terry wheeler

professor, museum director, entomologist, ecologist, naturalist
This entry was posted in Science Culture and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Sometimes, a shirt is not just a shirt

  1. Peter Desmet says:

    Update: Matt Taylor has apologized for his very, very poor choice of shirt:

    Note: the comet is about 500,000,000 km away from us, so even more impressive. 🙂

  2. Melanie says:

    You put this so well. I wish more of the older men who hold high positions in academia shared your way of thinking.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s